Ways to be heard

Are the five stages of grief real? What research says

Where the five stages of grief came from, what studies of bereaved people found instead (yearning, waves, different paths), and what helped people.

Are the five stages of grief real? What research says — article illustration

By the Ember team · Published November 20, 2026 · 6 min read

Someone told you about the five stages: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance. Months later, you can't say which one you're in. The anger never came. Some days feel almost calm; then a song in the grocery store undoes you. Did you skip one, or get stuck?

In a Yale study of 233 bereaved people, the main painful feeling in the two years after a death wasn't disbelief, anger or depression. It was yearning: missing the person.

The short answer is that the stages came from Elisabeth Kübler-Ross's work with dying patients, not from studying grief. Studies of bereaved people found the feelings, but not an order most people follow. Missing the person runs through it, grief comes and goes, and paths differ: in older widowed people, the most common one was steady.

Talk it out on Ember

What the research says so far

Utrecht University and UMass Boston, 2017. Margaret Stroebe, Henk Schut and Kathrin Boerner reviewed the stage theory of grief. Kübler-Ross drew the stages in her 1969 book On Death and Dying from her contact with more than two hundred dying patients, not a systematic study of bereaved people. She applied them to families in the same book, and they spread to grief from there. The review concludes that most people don't grieve in stages, and that expecting them can harm those who don't. Her later co-author, David Kessler, writes on his site that not everyone goes through all of them, or in a set order. What it doesn't show: that the feelings aren't real; people do feel some of them at times.

Yale University, 2007. Paul Maciejewski, Holly Prigerson and colleagues asked 233 bereaved people in Connecticut, one month to two years after a death, about disbelief, yearning, anger, depression and acceptance. Acceptance was reported most often; yearning was the main painful feeling throughout. In averaged, adjusted scores, the painful feelings peaked one after another while acceptance kept rising; the authors read that as support for stages, and other researchers questioned the study's design. What it doesn't show: that any one person goes through them in order.

Columbia University and NYU, 2002 and 2012. George Bonanno and colleagues followed 205 older people from years before their husband or wife died to 18 months after. Of five patterns, the one long assumed to be typical, distress rising after the death and then easing, was relatively rare; the most common was resilience, low and steady. A 2012 reanalysis of 301 people from the same study, followed to four years, found 66% with little or no depression throughout, and 9% whose depression rose sharply, stayed high at 18 months, and had eased by year four; the rest had been depressed before the death. What it doesn't show: that the steady group didn't miss their spouse; this tracked depression, not missing. Nearly nine in ten in the reanalysis were women; all lived near Detroit, first interviewed in 1987–88. If it was your husband or wife: the nights and the empty house.

Utrecht University, 1999 and 2010. Stroebe and Schut's dual process model describes grieving people moving between the loss itself (missing them, going over the death) and the life that changed (money, a new role): facing each at times, turning away at others, and sometimes taking time out. In their 2010 update: "respite at times is recuperative." Trouble is expected mainly when someone stays almost entirely on one side. What it doesn't show: it's a model, and its authors say the back-and-forth is hard to measure and needs more testing.

None of this says anger or bargaining means something is wrong. The feelings don't keep a schedule. If it was your father and the tears haven't come: what people grieving their father asked.

Keeping a bond

Last century, researchers mostly saw holding on to the person who died as getting in the way of grieving. Newer work describes a relationship that changes rather than ends, called a continuing bond: telling stories about them, keeping their things, letting their values shape your days, even talking to them. A Heidelberg University team describes it as a source of solace, though whether it helps seems to depend on its form, which is still being worked out. On Ember, people grieving someone close who found a way to carry it often looked for ways to stay connected rather than moving on: whether grief got lighter for them.

What helped people

  • Telling it, then telling it again. In the dual process model, attention shifts slowly and unevenly from going over the death toward the days after. Telling it again is one way to hear where you are now.
  • Keeping no one's timetable. The 2017 review describes people worried they weren't feeling the stages "in the right order," and says not going through them doesn't mean grief has gone wrong. In the dual process model, a day off from grief is part of grieving.
  • Hearing from people who lost someone the same way. A husband after a long illness isn't a mother lost suddenly. How it went for others in the same kind of loss gives your days something to set beside. Where to find them.
  • Letting someone in on the hard days. Most bereaved people, the review notes, do fine with the people around them; a minority need professional help. A sister, a neighbor who knew them, or a counselor of your own can carry part of it with you.

How we built Ember around this

Ember is an AI. It can't tell you where you are in your grief, or when it will ease.

You can say what's going on, by text or voice, any hour. Ember listens and tries to understand what you mean. It won't tell you how to grieve, or when it's time to be done. Behind the conversation is what real people in similar situations went through, what they tried, and what happened next, so Ember can tell you how it went for people who've been there.

Nothing you tell becomes a public post. No one can read your Ember unless you separately say yes. Ember is an AI; it isn't therapy or an emergency service.

When you need more than a place to think

An AI is not a counselor, a therapist, or an emergency service. If missing them has turned into not wanting to be here yourself, or into thoughts of harming yourself, you don't have to be sure it's serious enough: you can call or text 988 any time to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. If you are in immediate danger, call 911. Where to talk about grief goes through in-person options, from hospice grief groups to counselors.

Frequently asked questions

Are the five stages of grief real?
They name feelings many grieving people have at some point. But they came from work with dying patients, and studies of bereaved people haven't found most people moving through them in order.

What order do the stages of grief go in?
The usual list is denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance. Studies of bereaved people haven't found that most follow it; in a Yale study, acceptance was the most common reaction and yearning the main painful one.

Is there a right way to grieve?
Research describes several normal ways, not one. In a long study of older widowed people, the most common path was steady; the one long assumed typical was relatively rare.

What is Ember?
Ember is an AI you can talk to about what's on your mind, any hour, by voice or text. It listens, remembers what you said, and knows how things went for people who stood where you're standing — what they tried, and what happened after. It won't tell you what to do.

Is Ember private, and does it cost anything?
Ember is private: nothing you tell becomes a public post, and no one can read your Ember unless you separately say yes. Ember is in beta, and we’re gradually moving to paid subscriptions. If you’re asked to subscribe, you’ll see the price before anything is charged, and you can cancel anytime. Ember is for adults 18+.


There's no stage you're supposed to have reached by now. Where you are today is a fine place to start.

Talk it out on Ember
Pause or stop anytime · 18+ · Nothing you tell becomes a public post.