Ways to be heard

What is anticipatory grief? What research says

What anticipatory grief is, including in dementia, whether grieving ahead makes the loss easier after, what research can't say, and what helped families.

What is anticipatory grief? What research says — article illustration

By the Ember team · Published November 21, 2026 · 6 min read

Your mother is still here. She still likes the chair by the window. But the woman who called every Sunday has been slipping away for months, and you catch yourself grieving her, then feeling guilty for it. Is this anticipatory grief? Is it normal, and will it make the end any easier?

When researchers in St. Louis talked with 87 spouses and grown children of people with dementia, their findings suggested that grief before the death is "real" grief, as intense and wide-ranging as the grief that follows one.

The short answer is that anticipatory grief is grief that starts before a death, for what's already gone and what's still coming. It was long thought to be a head start that would leave less for later. Studies of caregivers haven't found that: heavy grief before a death tended to go with harder grief after, and feeling prepared with doing better. It can come alongside love, not instead of it.

Talk it out on Ember

What the research says so far

The term goes back to a 1944 paper on acute grief by Erich Lindemann, at Massachusetts General Hospital. For decades it was taken as an early start on grieving. Whether it helps, harms, or has nothing to do with grief after the death has been argued since, without agreement, as Leiden anthropologist Natashe Lemos Dekker notes in a 2022 study.

Washington University in St. Louis and University of Missouri–St. Louis, 2001 and 2002. Thomas Meuser and Samuel Marwit held focus groups with 87 spouses and grown children of people with dementia, at each stage and after the death. From what caregivers said, the authors built an inventory with three parts: personal sacrifice burden, heartfelt sadness and longing, and worry and felt isolation. What it doesn't show: how common this grief is, or how it shapes grief after the death.

Aarhus University, 2016 and 2017. Mette Kjaergaard Nielsen and colleagues reviewed studies from 1990 to 2015 of adults caring for someone at the end of life. The idea that grieving ahead eases bereavement wasn't confirmed: high grief during caregiving went with poorer outcomes afterward, such as complicated grief, and feeling prepared with better ones. In their national Danish study of 2,215 bereaved caregivers, grief was higher before the death than six months after, and severe grief beforehand was a key predictor of complicated grief, which 7.6% had. What it doesn't show: cause. These are associations.

Hebrew SeniorLife, Boston, 2011. Jane Givens and colleagues followed 123 family members, mostly grown children, of nursing home residents with advanced dementia. Grief stayed about the same from before the death to seven months after; longing and thoughts of the death were most common throughout. Higher grief beforehand went with higher grief later; it did "not appear to be protective," the authors write. What it doesn't show: families everywhere. Grief was fairly low overall, in mostly white, college-educated families near Boston.

University of Pittsburgh, 2003 and 2006. Richard Schulz and colleagues followed 217 family caregivers through a relative's last year with dementia. Their depressive symptoms were high during the caregiving and much lower within a year of the death; 72% said the death was a relief to them. In a 2006 paper on 217 bereaved caregivers, 20% had complicated grief, more often those with high depression and burden beforehand. What it doesn't show: missing the person. The 2003 paper tracked depression, not grief.

None of this means grieving now is a mistake, or says how it will go for you. The researchers' point: people carrying heavy grief while caring for someone need support then, not only after. If the death has already come, the five stages of grief and grief after a partner dies are closer to where you are.

Here, and not here

Pauline Boss, at the University of Minnesota, coined the term "ambiguous loss" in the 1970s. The university's site on her work describes one kind as a person physically present but psychologically absent, as in dementia: no death to mark, and no certainty they'll come back as they were. Such loss "freezes the grief process."

Lemos Dekker spent 18 months in Dutch nursing homes. Families told her they had "already lost" the person, yet kept looking for what was "still possible." One son brought his mother good white wine every Sunday and let her smell it first: "every glass could be her last one." A daughter said: "she is there, but also isn't."

If it's mostly fear of what's coming, people on Ember asked whether that fear eases, and how anyone finds peace as parents get older.

What helped some families while the person was still here

  • Letting the missing and the loving sit side by side. Normalizing ambivalence is one of Boss's guidelines for ambiguous loss. In the Dutch homes, the grief and the wine came on the same visit.
  • Putting it into words, even once. On Ember, some people afraid of losing someone to a serious illness said the fear and the love out loud to the person. It didn't change the illness; it left them a little better.
  • Learning how the later stages went for other caregivers. The move to a care home, the last months. Where to find them.
  • Support during the caregiving, not only after. In the Pittsburgh study, caregivers in a program easing depression and burden reported less complicated grief later. Time off can bring its own guilt, and some have no break at all.

How we built Ember around this

Ember is an AI. It can't tell you how much time is left.

You can say what's going on, by text or voice, any hour. Ember listens and tries to understand what you mean. It won't tell you what to do, or how to feel. Behind the conversation is what real people in similar situations went through, what they tried, and what happened next, so Ember can tell you how it went for people who've been there.

Nothing you tell becomes a public post. No one can read your Ember unless you separately say yes. Ember is an AI; it isn't therapy or an emergency service.

When you need more than a place to think

An AI is not a counselor, a therapist, a doctor, or an emergency service. If the grief has turned into despair, or into thoughts of harming yourself, you don't have to be sure it's serious enough: you can call or text 988 any time to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. If you are in immediate danger, call 911. For help with the care, the Eldercare Locator connects families to local services for older adults: 1-800-677-1116, by call or text. Where to talk about caring for a parent goes through more options.

Frequently asked questions

What is anticipatory grief?
Grief that starts before a death: for what's already lost, like who a parent used to be, and for the loss to come. One study of dementia caregivers suggested it is as intense as grief after a death.

Is it normal to grieve someone who is still alive?
Many caregivers describe it. In a Dutch nursing home study, families often said they had "already lost" the person, while still finding ways to be close.

Does anticipatory grief make grief easier after the death?
Studies of caregivers haven't found that. Heavy grief before a death went with harder grief after; feeling prepared went with doing better.

What is Ember?
Ember is an AI you can talk to about what's on your mind, any hour, by voice or text. It listens, remembers what you said, and knows how things went for people who stood where you're standing — what they tried, and what happened after. It won't tell you what to do.

Is Ember private, and does it cost anything?
Ember is private: nothing you tell becomes a public post, and no one can read your Ember unless you separately say yes. Ember is in beta, and we’re gradually moving to paid subscriptions. If you’re asked to subscribe, you’ll see the price before anything is charged, and you can cancel anytime. Ember is for adults 18+.


You can miss who they were and still love who they are, in the same visit.

Talk it out on Ember
Pause or stop anytime · 18+ · Nothing you tell becomes a public post.